Logo
Who We Are What We Do How We Think Our People News & Insights
Schedule a Consultation
+1-321-206-3603

Have Questions? Let's Chat
Se habla Español

Schedule a Consultation
Who We Are What We Do How We Think Our People News & Insights Schedule a Consultation +1-321-206-3603
icon

Meet Locally in Melbourne or Save the Trip and Meet Virtually. Serving all 67 Florida Counties.

  • Home >
  • Business

Published: Sep 19, 2020

Updated: Dec 8, 2023

McConville v. SEC: Widening the Net through Falsities and Scienter

By Andrew David Easler, Esq.

Published: Sep 19, 2020

Updated: Dec 8, 2023

McConville v. United States involved a petition for review of an order of the Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) finding violations of several sections of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 by the chief financial officer of Akorn Incorporated.[1] Akorn Incorporated manufactured and sold diagnostic and therapeutic pharmaceuticals to wholesalers and end-use consumers.[2] Akorn would process and keep track of its orders using various rates, corporate credits, and payment schedules (e.g. current, thirty to sixty days past due, etc.).[3] Akorn used a system that involved three different financing offices and used different computer programs and record-keeping mechanisms to track its orders and payments.[4] Akorn tried using a new system to improve its record keeping but the system was incapable of tracking all of Akorn’s data.[5] The company switched to another software and it did not transfer the data from the previous software system to the new one.[6]

Between February 28, 1997 and March 20, 2001, Rita McConville (“Petitioner”) worked as chief financial officer (“CFO”) of the company and was responsible for (1) supervising the finance departments, (2) working with Akorn’s auditor, and (3) filing documents with the SEC.[7] In 2000, problems with the company’s financial records came to light.[8] First, Akorn’s auditor alerted the board of problems with the company’s financial record-keeping, e.g. misapplication of credits, failure to review accounts receivables, etc.[9] Second, a dispute arose between Akorn and one of its customers as a result of billing discrepancies amounting to close to $5 million.[10]

Despite these problems, Petitioner assured the auditor that the accounts were being reconciled.[11] Petitioner also participated in the drafting of financial documents during her time as CFO, including the 2000 Form 10-K.[12] Petitioner also signed two letters essentially stating that the financial statements did not need to be adjusted because no events had occurred after December, 2000 and after February, 2001 that had a material effect on the statements.[13] In 2002, Akorn restated its financial statements for the years 2000 and 2001.[14] Akorn reported that it had some errors in their financial statements, among other concerns, that the company had in fact sustained a net loss of $2.4 million in 2000 instead of the gain of $2 million it had initially reported.[15]

In 2003, the SEC started proceedings against Petitioner and the current CFO of Akorn alleging that Petitioner’s mismanagement of the financial department caused the company to file documents that were in violation of the federal securities laws.[16] The SEC found that Petitioner’s conduct violated Sections 10(b), 13(b)(2), and 13(b)(5) of the Securities Act of 1934 (“Act”), among others.[17] After the SEC’s findings, Petitioner filed a petition for review with the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh District.[18]

Under Section 10(b) of the Act, the Commission must show that Petitioner “(1) made a false statement or omission (2) of material fact (3) with scienter[19] (4) in connection with the purchase or sale of securities.”[20]  The issue was whether there was substantial evidence to support the Commission’s finding.[21]

Petitioner argued that the Commission did not prove the first and third elements by substantial evidence.[22] However, the appellate court found that the Commission proved the first element because Petitioner not only drafted Akorn’s financial statements, but she also reviewed and approved them, including the Form 10-K.[23] She also assured auditors that the documents were accurate and that no events had occurred that would make the documents misleading.[24] Therefore, the court concluded that Petitioner’s substantial involvement in the making of the documents and her statements to the auditors established that she made a false statement or omission.[25]

The court also found that the Commission proved the third element of scienter.[26] The court stated that “the requisite for scienter is an ‘extreme departure from the standards of ordinary care, which presents a danger of misleading buyers or sellers that is either known to the defendant or is so obvious that the actor must have been aware of it.’”[27] Here, the court found that Petitioner was aware of the problems in Akorn’s financial department and that she failed to disclose them in the financial statements.[28] For example, Petitioner stated that all customer accounts would be reconciled by a specific date, but this was not accomplished.[29] Despite this, Petitioner told auditors that nothing had occurred that would have made the financial statements misleading.[30] Therefore, the court concluded that Petitioner’s conduct occurred with recklessness and that the Commission proved the third element.[31] In addition, the appellate court found that there was substantial evidence that Petitioner violated SEC rules 13(b)(2) and 13(b)(5) of the Act.[32] As a result, the appellate court denied the petition for review.[33]

McConville highlights the importance of good record keeping. Purposely submitting inaccurate or false information in documents filed with the SEC is not the only method of running afoul with the commission. Bad tracking and recordkeeping that causes inaccurate reports, even if not intentional, may also lead to violations and charges with the SEC. It is also not necessary for a person to sign a document for it to be attributed to them, it is enough that the person was substantially involved in the process of making the document, e.g. drafting, reviewing, or affirming the document’s accuracy and content.

References:

[1] McConville v. United States, 465 F.3d 780 (7th Cir. 2006). [2] Id. at 782. [3] Id. [4] Id.  at 783.  [5] Id.  [6] McConville, 465 F.3d at 783. [7] Id.  [8] Id.  [9] Id.  [10] Id.  [11] McConville, 465 F.3d at 784. [12] Id. at 785 (A 10-K Form is a document reporting a corporation’s financial health to the SEC.).  [13] Id. [14] Id. [15] Id. at 786.  [16] McConville, 465 F.3d 786 (Petitioner was the CFO during the preparation of the documents filed with the SEC but was removed shortly before the company filed its financial statements with the SEC. She continued to work gathering information for the financial statements in her new position as corporate controller.). [17] Id. [18] Id. [19] While not defined in the regulations, the United States Supreme Court has described the term “scienter” as proscribing conduct evinced by an intent to deceive, manipulate, or defraud; see, Ernst & Ernst v. Hochfelder, 425 U.S. 185 (1976). [20] Id.  [21] Id. at 787. [22] McConville, 465 F.3d at 787. [23] Id.  [24] Id. at 788. [25] Id.  [26] Id.  [27] McConville, 465 F.3d at 788 (quoting Makor Issues & Rights, Ltd. v. Tellabs, Inc., 437 F.3d 588, 600 (7th Cir. 2006)). [28] Id.  [29] Id.  [30] Id.  [31] Id. at 789. [32] McConville, 465 F.3d at 789-90 (The opinion also explains how Petitioner violated rules 13(b)(2) and 13(b)(5) but the focus of this article was on rule 10(b)).  [33] Id. at 790.

Disclaimer

We give great legal advice, but this page (and the rest of our site) is for informational use only and is no substitute for actual legal advice. If you’d like to establish an attorney-client relationship, reach out to us and we’ll tell you how we can make it official. Sending us an email or reading this page alone doesn’t mean we represent you.

Our Practice Areas

A real estate attorney specializes in property law, helping clients navigate the complexities of buying, selling, and managing real estate, ensuring that transactions comply with state laws and regulations, and providing protection and peace of mind.

Responsibilities of an attorney include drafting and reviewing contracts, negotiating terms, and resolving complex issues such as zoning, leasing, property development, and disputes involving boundaries or titles. Real estate attorneys are also skilled in handling litigation related to construction defects and other property disputes, helping to resolve these matters effectively and prevent potential legal challenges.

By conducting due diligence and offering strategic legal advice, attorneys play an important role in safeguarding clients’ interests. Whether for individual homeowners or commercial property investors, real estate attorneys mitigate risks, represent clients in court, and assist them with making informed decisions that are legally sound.

Learn More About Real Estate Law Schedule a Consultation

Attorneys who practice business law provide legal advice for starting, managing, and expanding businesses, ensuring compliance with applicable laws. Their expertise covers various duties, including drafting and reviewing contracts, advising on corporate governance, facilitating business transactions such as mergers and acquisitions, forming partnerships, LLCs, and other business entities like DBAs, drafting and reviewing LLC Operating Agreements, and assisting with strategic planning.

Business attorneys also help wtih legal matters such as intellectual property rights, disputes, franchising, and regulatory compliance, represent clients in civil litigation to resolve issues like contract breaches and other civil matters, offer advice on administrative and compliance requirements, assist clients who are buying or selling businesses, and even help plan for succession and asset protection.

Attorneys help mitigate risks, safeguard company interests, assist clients in making legally sound, informed decisions, help manage growth, and provide guidance to navigate and resolve legal challenges effectively. Their strategic insights are invaluable in ensuring business operations align with legal standards and long-term objectives.

Learn More About Business Law Schedule a Consultation

Probate attorneys actively manage the estate administration process following an individual's death, ensuring the distribution of assets aligns with the will or state law, and handle Formal Probate Administration for complex cases, Summary Administration for smaller estates, and Ancillary Administration for assets in other states.

Responsibilities of probate attorneys include filing petitions, appointing personal representatives to manage estate affairs, notifying interested parties to ensure transparency and prevent disputes, helping conduct an inventory and appraisal of the estate's assets, overseeing the payment of debts and expenses, handling probate litigation to resolve any disputes that arise.

They also assist in distributing the assets and formally closing the estate, ensuring all legal and financial responsibilities are met, simplifying the complex probate process, honoring the decedent's wishes, and providing clarity and support to the beneficiaries.

Learn More About Probate Schedule a Consultation

Will and trust attorneys help draft legal documents to ensure their clients' wishes for asset distribution are executed correctly. They draft personalized and legally compliant wills to designate beneficiaries, appoint executors, and establish trusts for asset management and distribution. It is important to note that wills and trusts are an integral part of the estate planning process.

Responsibilities of wills and trust attorneys include providing legal advice and guidance related to asset protection, minimizing tax obligations, facilitating efficient wealth transfer to designated heirs, offering advice on appointing guardians for minor children, and drafting healthcare directives for unforeseen circumstances.

By providing tailored legal advice and crafting personalized documents, attorneys help clients safeguard their legacies, protect loved ones, and ensure that all documents are both legally compliant and enforceable.

Learn More About Wills & Trusts Schedule a Consultation

Estate planning attorneys provide advice and legal guidance for managing and distributing assets in the event of death or incapacity and assist individuals of various financial backgrounds in preparing essential legal documents such as wills, trusts, and Lady Bird Deeds, and may offer advanced techniques like offshore trusts and family-limited partnerships.

Experienced attorneys offer personalized legal advice, tailoring strategies to meet individual client needs, and assist clients in navigating complex laws and regulations affecting asset management, taxation, and inheritance.

End-of-life planning safeguards wealth and secures a lasting legacy for heirs and charitable causes. Whether estates are modest or substantial, these plans provide invaluable peace of mind and financial security for future generations.

Learn More About Estate Planning Schedule a Consultation

Civil litigation attorneys manage disputes and represent their clients effectively with various legal matters and issues. They provide clear legal advice and handle all aspects of a case, from preparing documents to gathering evidence and preparing for trial. They also offer guidance and experience to help clients navigate the legal system efficiently, ensuring that cases are managed effectively and lead to timely outcomes.

Civil litigators are also skilled negotiators, often resolving disputes outside of court to save time and maintain relationships, which is particularly vital in business and probate matters.

When trials are necessary, they present and argue cases effectively to minimize losses and secure favorable outcomes. They offer continuous support and guidance throughout the litigation process, simplifying complex legal issues for their clients in both personal and business contexts.

Learn More About Civil Litigation Schedule a Consultation

Real Estate

A real estate attorney specializes in property law, helping clients navigate the complexities of buying, selling, and managing real estate, ensuring that transactions comply with state laws and regulations, and providing protection and peace of mind.

Responsibilities of an attorney include drafting and reviewing contracts, negotiating terms, and resolving complex issues such as zoning, leasing, property development, and disputes involving boundaries or titles. Real estate attorneys are also skilled in handling litigation related to construction defects and other property disputes, helping to resolve these matters effectively and prevent potential legal challenges.

By conducting due diligence and offering strategic legal advice, attorneys play an important role in safeguarding clients’ interests. Whether for individual homeowners or commercial property investors, real estate attorneys mitigate risks, represent clients in court, and assist them with making informed decisions that are legally sound.

Learn More About Real Estate Law Learn More arrow_forward calendar_today

Business

Attorneys who practice business law provide legal advice for starting, managing, and expanding businesses, ensuring compliance with applicable laws. Their expertise covers various duties, including drafting and reviewing contracts, advising on corporate governance, facilitating business transactions such as mergers and acquisitions, forming partnerships, LLCs, and other business entities like DBAs, drafting and reviewing LLC Operating Agreements, and assisting with strategic planning.

Business attorneys also help wtih legal matters such as intellectual property rights, disputes, franchising, and regulatory compliance, represent clients in civil litigation to resolve issues like contract breaches and other civil matters, offer advice on administrative and compliance requirements, assist clients who are buying or selling businesses, and even help plan for succession and asset protection.

Attorneys help mitigate risks, safeguard company interests, assist clients in making legally sound, informed decisions, help manage growth, and provide guidance to navigate and resolve legal challenges effectively. Their strategic insights are invaluable in ensuring business operations align with legal standards and long-term objectives.

Learn More About Business Law Learn More arrow_forward calendar_today

Probate

Probate attorneys actively manage the estate administration process following an individual's death, ensuring the distribution of assets aligns with the will or state law, and handle Formal Probate Administration for complex cases, Summary Administration for smaller estates, and Ancillary Administration for assets in other states.

Responsibilities of probate attorneys include filing petitions, appointing personal representatives to manage estate affairs, notifying interested parties to ensure transparency and prevent disputes, helping conduct an inventory and appraisal of the estate's assets, overseeing the payment of debts and expenses, handling probate litigation to resolve any disputes that arise.

They also assist in distributing the assets and formally closing the estate, ensuring all legal and financial responsibilities are met, simplifying the complex probate process, honoring the decedent's wishes, and providing clarity and support to the beneficiaries.

Learn More About Probate Learn More arrow_forward calendar_today

Wills & Trusts

Will and trust attorneys help draft legal documents to ensure their clients' wishes for asset distribution are executed correctly. They draft personalized and legally compliant wills to designate beneficiaries, appoint executors, and establish trusts for asset management and distribution. It is important to note that wills and trusts are an integral part of the estate planning process.

Responsibilities of wills and trust attorneys include providing legal advice and guidance related to asset protection, minimizing tax obligations, facilitating efficient wealth transfer to designated heirs, offering advice on appointing guardians for minor children, and drafting healthcare directives for unforeseen circumstances.

By providing tailored legal advice and crafting personalized documents, attorneys help clients safeguard their legacies, protect loved ones, and ensure that all documents are both legally compliant and enforceable.

Learn More About Wills & Trusts Learn More arrow_forward calendar_today

Estate Planning

Estate planning attorneys provide advice and legal guidance for managing and distributing assets in the event of death or incapacity and assist individuals of various financial backgrounds in preparing essential legal documents such as wills, trusts, and Lady Bird Deeds, and may offer advanced techniques like offshore trusts and family-limited partnerships.

Experienced attorneys offer personalized legal advice, tailoring strategies to meet individual client needs, and assist clients in navigating complex laws and regulations affecting asset management, taxation, and inheritance.

End-of-life planning safeguards wealth and secures a lasting legacy for heirs and charitable causes. Whether estates are modest or substantial, these plans provide invaluable peace of mind and financial security for future generations.

Learn More About Estate Planning Learn More arrow_forward calendar_today

Civil Litigation

Civil litigation attorneys manage disputes and represent their clients effectively with various legal matters and issues. They provide clear legal advice and handle all aspects of a case, from preparing documents to gathering evidence and preparing for trial. They also offer guidance and experience to help clients navigate the legal system efficiently, ensuring that cases are managed effectively and lead to timely outcomes.

Civil litigators are also skilled negotiators, often resolving disputes outside of court to save time and maintain relationships, which is particularly vital in business and probate matters.

When trials are necessary, they present and argue cases effectively to minimize losses and secure favorable outcomes. They offer continuous support and guidance throughout the litigation process, simplifying complex legal issues for their clients in both personal and business contexts.

Learn More About Civil Litigation Learn More arrow_forward calendar_today

Founded in 2021 by Attorneys with Real-World Experience

Legal Questions Answered

Frequent Asked Questions

Our FAQ section provides general answers to common legal questions but is not a substitute for legal advice. Always consult a licensed attorney for personalized guidance.

Need more help?
Schedule a Consultation

Our attorneys actively prepare for each consultation by reviewing the information you provide beforehand. This preparation ensures that potential clients receive valuable legal advice and information, maximizing the value of your time with us.

Speak with an Attorney +1-321-206-3603

People also read about...

Publications

Can a Landlord ask for Proof of a Dog’s ADA Service Animal Status?


Read More arrow_forward
View Knowledge Hub

Search pages, our insights, and more all from one place

+1-321-206-3603 Schedule a Consultation

Trusted by 1000+ Clients.

Easler Law offers legal advice and consults involving real estate, business law, probate, wills and trusts, estate planning, and civil litigation. Our attorneys are licensed in Florida, operate from Melbourne, Florida, and virtually serve clients across all 67 Florida counties.

+1-321-206-3603 Schedule a Consultation

Have Questions? Let’s Chat +1-321-206-3603

Se habla Español

Monday-Friday 9 AM to 5 PM EST.

Closed on weekends and holidays.

[email protected]

Logo

Read our Terms, Privacy Policy, and DMCA Policy. We are an Equal Opportunity Employer and are committed to Accessibility. Explore open job positions and our affiliates QuickDeeds.com®, BusinessHelp.com®, and WorkTraining.com®. Discover resources for small businesses through the SBA and view Sunbiz process times. Legal services and financial help are available through Legal Aid. Also, consider supporting Ukraine and Animal Legal Defence.

© 2021-2024 Easler Law, PLLC or its affiliates. All rights reserved.